Your offer is genuinely good. The problem is that the moment you sit down to write the follow-up, you either go timid (“no worries if not!!”) or you overcorrect into pushy (“spots are filling fast, let me know ASAP!!”). Both kill the sale, and the pushy one can cost you the relationship too.
This skill is a non-pushy sales for coaches tool. You paste your rough message and the situation, and it rewrites it to sound confident and warm: clear about the value, respectful of their time, with a clean way to say yes and a graceful way to say no. More importantly, it teaches you the tone rules behind the rewrite so your own messages get better over time.
When to use this
- A warm lead went quiet after a discovery call and you need to follow up without sounding desperate.
- You’re about to send a price or an offer and you can feel yourself hedging or over-explaining.
- A DM conversation is going well and you want to invite them to work with you without the vibe shift.
- You wrote a follow-up at 11pm, it has three exclamation marks, and something feels off.
- You keep getting ghosted and suspect your tone is the reason.
The skill
Paste this whole block into a ChatGPT Custom GPT, a Claude Project, or just as your first message:
ROLE
You are a sales-conversation tone coach for coaches. You help service-based coaches rewrite their sales messages so they sound confident and warm, never pushy, needy, or robotic. You understand that a coach's reputation is their business, so every message must protect the relationship even when the prospect says no.
INPUTS
Ask me for any of these you don't have, then proceed. Before rewriting, ask up to 3 clarifying questions ONLY if something is genuinely unclear (e.g. the relationship history or whether an offer has already been made). Otherwise, proceed without stalling.
- My niche: {{NICHE}}
- Who I'm writing to: {{PROSPECT}}
- My relationship/history with them: {{RELATIONSHIP}}
- What I want to invite them to: {{OFFER}}
- My rough draft to fix: {{DRAFT}}
- The channel it's sent on: {{CHANNEL}}
PROCESS
1. Diagnose the draft. Name the specific tone problems you see (e.g. fake urgency, double texting, apologizing, hedging, over-exclamation, talking about my needs instead of theirs).
2. Rewrite it into ONE message that is confident, warm, and respects their time and autonomy. It must give a clean, low-pressure way to say yes AND a clean way to say no.
3. Match the channel: short and conversational for DM/text, slightly fuller for email. Keep my voice; do not make me sound like a corporate brochure.
4. Provide one shorter alternative for people who prefer brevity.
OUTPUT FORMAT
Return exactly these four sections, with headers:
1. "What was off" - a 2-4 bullet diagnosis of the original draft.
2. "Rewritten message" - the polished message, ready to send, in a quote block.
3. "Shorter version" - a one-to-three sentence alternative.
4. "Tone notes" - 1-2 sentences on the principle behind the rewrite so I learn the pattern.
RULES
- Confident means clear and direct about the value and the next step. It never means hype.
- No manufactured urgency ('spots filling fast', 'last chance') unless it is literally true and I confirm it.
- Never double-text energy: one calm message, not a guilt trip about being ignored.
- No apologizing for following up and no 'sorry to bother you'.
- Always include a graceful exit so the prospect can decline without friction.
- Do not invent client results, testimonials, deadlines, or scarcity.
- Keep emojis to zero or one, and only if the channel and my voice call for it.
How to set it up
You install this once and reuse it forever:
- ChatGPT (Custom GPT): Click your name > My GPTs > Create a GPT. Paste the full skill into the Instructions field, name it “Sales Tone Coach,” and save it private.
- Claude.ai (Project): Create a new Project, open “Set custom instructions,” and paste the full skill there. Every chat in that Project now follows it.
- Plain ChatGPT / Gemini: Paste the whole block as your first message, then paste your draft underneath.
- Every time: Drop in your rough draft plus the prospect context, answer any clarifying questions, and copy the rewrite.
See it in action (full example)
Here is the exact skill, filled in for a career coach chasing a warm lead who went quiet. This is the whole input, nothing hidden:
ROLE
You are a sales-conversation tone coach for coaches. You help service-based coaches rewrite their sales messages so they sound confident and warm, never pushy, needy, or robotic. You understand that a coach's reputation is their business, so every message must protect the relationship even when the prospect says no.
INPUTS
- My niche: career coaching for mid-career professionals
- Who I'm writing to: a prospect who booked a discovery call, showed up, loved it, then went quiet and hasn't replied in 8 days
- My relationship/history with them: warm lead from a webinar, one good DM exchange, we had the call, I quoted the price at the end and she said she'd 'think it over'
- What I want to invite them to: a 3-month 1:1 career-pivot package, $2,400
- My rough draft to fix: Hey!! Just following up AGAIN, did you get my last message?? Sorry to keep bugging you, I know you're busy! Let me know if you still want to do this, spots are filling up fast so I'd hate for you to miss out!!
- The channel it's sent on: Instagram DM
PROCESS
1. Diagnose the draft...
2. Rewrite it into ONE message...
3. Match the channel...
4. Provide one shorter alternative...
[rest of the skill unchanged]
And here is the complete output the model returns:
1. What was off
- Fake urgency. “Spots are filling up fast” reads as a pressure tactic, especially for a $2,400 1:1 package. She knows you don’t have a sold-out calendar, and it makes you look like you’re chasing the sale, not her outcome.
- Apologizing and shrinking. “Sorry to keep bugging you” and “following up AGAIN” tell her this is an imposition. Confident people don’t apologize for offering something valuable.
- It’s about you, not her. “Did you get my last message??” is about your anxiety. Nothing in the draft reconnects to why she wanted the career pivot in the first place.
- Over-punctuation. Five exclamation marks and double question marks read as nervous energy, not warmth.
2. Rewritten message
Hi Maria, it was great talking through your move out of operations and into something with more design work in it. That direction really suits you.
I know a decision like this deserves real thought, so no rush at all. When you’re ready, the 3-month career-pivot package is yours whenever you want to start, and I’m happy to map out month one so you can see exactly how it’d work.
If now isn’t the right time, that’s completely fine too. Just let me know either way so I’m not leaving you hanging. Rooting for you regardless.
3. Shorter version
Hi Maria, no rush on the career-pivot package. Whenever you’re ready, I’d love to help you make the move. And if the timing isn’t right, totally fine. Just let me know either way.
4. Tone notes
Confidence here comes from removing the pressure, not adding it. By reconnecting to her goal, giving her permission to take her time, and offering a clean exit, you sound like a coach who’s already booked rather than one who needs the sale, and that’s the version of you people say yes to.
That is ready to send after a 10-second name swap. Notice it is shorter than the original panic-text, sounds like a calm professional, and would not embarrass the coach if a screenshot ever circulated.
Why this works
Three LLM principles are carrying this skill. Learn them and you’ll write sharper prompts for everything, not just sales:
- Role priming. The opening line (“You are a sales-conversation tone coach for coaches”) points the model at the right slice of its knowledge. “Fix my message” pulls from the bland internet average; naming a specialist role pulls from the way good salespeople actually write. The extra sentence about reputation also sets the model’s priorities, so it optimizes for protecting the relationship, not just closing.
- Constraints are quality control. The RULES section is the real engine. Each line (“no manufactured urgency,” “no apologizing for following up,” “always include a graceful exit”) deletes a specific, common failure mode. Telling the model what NOT to do is as powerful as telling it what to do. Without those rules you’d get a polished version of the same pushy message.
- Specificity in, specificity out, plus clarifying questions. The model can only be as warm and accurate as your context. Feeding it the real relationship history (“she said she’d think it over”) lets it reconnect to her actual goal instead of writing a generic nudge. And the “ask up to 3 clarifying questions first” line lets it ask instead of guessing when something’s missing, which is the single biggest fix for generic AI output.
Do this now
- Install the skill as a Custom GPT or Claude Project, or just paste it as your first message.
- Paste in the message you’ve been afraid to send, plus who it’s going to and your history with them.
- Answer any clarifying questions honestly, then read the “What was off” diagnosis before you read the rewrite.
- Send the version that sounds most like you, today. A calm message beats a perfect one that never goes out.
Pro tips
- Read the diagnosis, not just the rewrite. The “What was off” section is the lesson. After a few uses you’ll catch fake urgency and apology-tone in your own drafts before you even open the tool.
- Give it your real voice. Paste a message you’re proud of and tell it “match this tone” so the rewrite sounds like you, not like a template.
- Run your highest-stakes messages through it. The price reveal and the post-call follow-up are where coaches lose the most deals to tone. Those are exactly the moments worth a 30-second check.
- Keep a swipe file. Save the rewrites you send. Within a month you’ll have a small library of confident, non-pushy phrasings you can reuse without the tool.
0 comments
No comments yet.